Classic Ice Cream Sandwich Cookie

Batch Size:
Yield:

Main

AmountIngredient
Unsalted Butter
Chocolate
Granulated Sugar
Whole Eggs
Coffee Extract
Vanilla Extract2 t
All-purpose Flour
Unsweetened Cocoa Powder
Baking Powder1 t
Salt¼ tsp
Scaled ingredient total1,040.25 g

Prep Method 7

  1. 1.Melt the butter and chocolate over a water bath.
  2. 2.Whisk the sugar into the melted butter/chocolate mixture to combine, followed by the eggs and extracts until smooth.
  3. 3.Whisk the sifted dry ingredients into the wet ingredients until smooth and homogenous.
  4. 4.Spread the batter onto two half sheet pans and bake at 350°F (177°C) until dry to the touch.
  5. 5.Line a frozen, flat half sheet pan with plastic wrap. Spread softened ice cream onto the pan and level smooth. Freeze until firm.
  6. 6.Unmold the frozen ice cream onto one of the cookies, then top with the other. Wrap and freeze until firm.
  7. 7.Unwrap sandwich and using a serrated knife, cut into rectangles, wiping off blade between cuts.

U of M Equivalency

XX Weight = XX Volume = XX Each

If you would like to use this recipe by weight, volume, and even by the portion - you can customize that here.For example, if your recipe yields 1 quart, weighs 850 grams, and each portion is 85 grams, toggle off the standard conversion and enter '850 grams = 1 quart = 10 portions'.

Standard Weight - Volume ConversionWhen toggled on, conversions are locked to 8oz = 1 cup. Toggle off to customize.
Weight
=
Volume
=
Each

Recipe Cost

There is not enough information to calculate cost. Please verify the below:
  • This recipe and all its sub-recipes must include Total Yield
  • All ingredients in this recipe and its sub-recipes must be defined
  • All ingredients in this recipe and its sub-recipes must have a purchase cost
  • All ingredients in this recipe and its sub-recipes must have the needed unit conversion to convert from the unit in the recipe to the purchase unit
  • If this recipe exists in multiple concepts or locations, there is a cost at each concept/location

Ingredient and sub-recipe costs used to calculate this recipe.

Ingredient / Sub-Recipe ( | )Cost
Unsalted Butter$1.6865
Purchase item nameGreat Value Sweet Cream Unsalted Butter, 16 oz, 4 Sticks
Purchase cost$3.06
Purchase unit16 ounce_mass
Date added2026-08-08
Item ID #10315054
Vendorwalmart
ChocolateThis ingredient is not yet set with a purchase cost and unit
Granulated Sugar$0.2901
Purchase item name10 LB SUGAR
Purchase cost$6.58
Purchase unit10 pound
Date added2026-07-10
Item ID #980250647.0
Vendorsams_club
Whole EggsThis ingredient is not yet set with a purchase cost and unit
Coffee ExtractThis ingredient is not yet set with a purchase cost and unit
Vanilla ExtractThis ingredient is not yet set with a purchase cost and unit
All-purpose Flour$0.2624
Purchase item nameGreat Value All-Purpose Enriched Bleached Wheat Flour, 5 lb Bag
Purchase cost$2.38
Purchase unit5 pound
Date added2025-11-26
Item ID #10403017
Vendorwalmart
Unsweetened Cocoa PowderThis ingredient is not yet set with a purchase cost and unit
Baking PowderThis ingredient is not yet set with a purchase cost and unit
Salt$0.0011
Purchase item nameGreat Value Iodized Salt, 26 oz
Purchase cost$0.67
Purchase unit26 ounce_mass
Date added2024-10-27
Item ID #10448316
Vendorwalmart
Total Yield1,040 g
Total Cost$2.2402
Cost Per G:$0.0022
Cost Per Serving$1.1201

Partial estimate; unpriced ingredients are excluded. 67% of ingredient weight is priced.

6 costing issues
  • Chocolate: no active USD purchase price with a convertible package size
  • Whole Eggs: no active USD purchase price with a convertible package size
  • Coffee Extract: no active USD purchase price with a convertible package size
  • Vanilla Extract: no active USD purchase price with a convertible package size
  • Unsweetened Cocoa Powder: no active USD purchase price with a convertible package size
  • Baking Powder: no active USD purchase price with a convertible package size

Nutrition Facts

2 servings per scaled recipe

Serving size1 serving (520 g)

Amount per serving

Calories950

% Daily Value*

Total Fat 111g
142%
Saturated Fat 2.5g
13%
Cholesterol 480mg
160%
Sodium 600mg
26%
Total Carbohydrate 201g
73%
Dietary Fiber 8g
29%
Total Sugars 1g
Protein 24g

* The % Daily Value tells you how much a nutrient in a serving contributes to a daily diet. A 2,000 calorie diet is used for general nutrition advice.

Draft calculation · 81% mapped. Scaled batch: 1904 kcal. Nutrition and allergen analysis must be professionally verified before regulatory use.

Additional details

  • Yield: two half sheet pans